In the Indian startup ecosystem, effective accounts payable processes are not just a necessity—they are crucial for survival and growth. Inefficient accounts payable processes can lead to overpayments, missed payments, frauds, and strained relationships with suppliers, ultimately affecting the startup’s cash flow and reputation. Therefore, having a streamlined and accurate accounts payable system, possibly through accounts payable automation , is essential.
This guide aims to help you with the concepts of 2-way, 3-way , and 4-way matching in accounts payable, processes that are integral to verifying supplier invoices and ensuring accurate payments. Understanding what is 2-way and 3-way matching in accounts payable will help startup founders implement robust invoice processing checks, prevent vendor and employee fraud, and maintain healthy cash flow.
We will dive into the definitions and processes of 2-way, 3-way, and 4-way matching, explore their benefits and challenges, and discuss how automation can enhance these processes. By the end of this guide, you will have a comprehensive understanding of how these matching techniques, including what is 2 way matching in accounts payable, what is 3 way matching in accounts payable, and what is 4 way matching in accounts payable, can fortify your accounts payable system and contribute to your startup’s success.
Matching: A Check in the Accounts Payable Process Matching is a critical step in the accounts payable (AP) process. It is an Invoice Processing Check that ensures the accuracy of your financial records and safeguards your company from fraud. It involves verifying information across different documents related to a purchase to confirm that you're paying for exactly what you ordered and received what you exactly paid for. This includes processes like two way matching in accounts payable.
The Procure-to-Pay Process and Matching Check The procure-to-pay (P2P) process is the lifeblood of any organization's spending. It encompasses the entire cycle, from identifying a need for goods or services to making the final payment to the supplier. Understanding this process is crucial for appreciating the significance of matching in accounts payable and vendor management since payables arise as a part of this process and the need for efficient vendor management partially arises as a result of the P2P process.
The Key Documents Involved in the Matching Process during the P2P Cycle Purchase Order (PO): A formal document issued by the buyer to the seller, acting as a legally binding agreement. It details the specific product or service being ordered, the quantity, agreed-upon price, and delivery terms.Invoice: A bill issued by the seller to the buyer, typically upon or after delivery of the product or service. It includes details like vendor information, customer information, product/service description, pricing, and payment terms.Goods Receipt: A document confirming the physical receipt of the ordered product or service from the vendor, often referred to as a goods received note.Inspection Slip (Required only for 4 Way Matching): Used primarily for complex equipment or critical materials, this document verifies that the received goods meet the agreed-upon quality standards through a formal inspection process.P2P Cycle Example Let's illustrate the P2P process with a different scenario. Imagine a marketing team at Startup X needs a specific type of promotional t-shirts for an upcoming event. Here's how it unfolds:
1. Identifying the Need: The marketing team drafts a purchase requisition detailing the desired t-shirt specifications (fabric, color, logo design) and the number needed for the event. They submit it for approval from their department head.
2. Selecting a Vendor: Once the requisition is approved, the procurement department searches for qualified apparel vendors. They shortlist a vendor, ABC Apparel, known for quality and competitive pricing.
3. Issuing the Purchase Order: After negotiation, a PO is generated for ABC Apparel specifying the exact t-shirt design, quantity (e.g., 200 units), and agreed-upon purchase order price per unit. Copies are distributed to ABC Apparel, procurement, and accounts payable.
4. Delivery and Receipt: ABC Apparel fulfills the order and delivers the t-shirts to Startup X. They also send an invoice along with the delivery or shortly thereafter. Upon receiving the shipment, the receiving department at Startup X meticulously counts the shirts and verifies the design matches the PO. They then generate a goods received note, confirming the quantity accepted.
5. The Matching Process: The accounts payable team at Startup X examines the PO, invoice, and goods receipt to ensure everything aligns. They check for discrepancies in quantity, design details, and pricing. In this case, they might also visually inspect a sample of the shirts to ensure quality matches expectations. If everything matches, payment is initiated to ABC Apparel, following the 2-way and 3-way match processes.
What is 2 Way Matching in Accounts Payable? 2-way matching is a core verification process in accounts payable (AP) that ensures you only pay for what you ordered and received. It involves comparing key details on the purchase order (PO) you issued to the invoice submitted by the vendor, addressing the question of what is two way matching in accounts payable.
Steps in The 2 Way Matching Process 1. The Invoice Arrives: After fulfilling your purchase order, the vendor sends an invoice detailing the goods or services provided and the amount due.
2. Matching the Purchase Order: The accounts payable team retrieves the corresponding PO associated with the invoice.
3. Automated or Manual Comparison: Technology can automate this step, but manual verification might also be used. The key elements compared include:
Quantity: The quantity billed on the invoice should be equal to or less than the quantity accepted and ordered on the PO.Price: The invoice price should be equal to or less than the purchase order price agreed upon in the PO (including any discounts).4. Two Possible Outcomes:
Tolerance Met: If the invoice details align perfectly with the PO within a predefined tolerance range (e.g., a slight variance in quantity due to rounding), the invoice is approved for payment.Tolerance Not Met: Any discrepancies exceeding the tolerance level trigger a hold on the invoice. The AP team investigates the issue and communicates with the vendor to resolve the mismatches and deviations, leading to invoice holds.5. Resolving Discrepancies: The vendor might need to correct the invoice or provide justification for the difference. Once the issue is addressed, the hold is lifted, and the invoice re-enters the approval process.
6. Payment Approval: Upon successful verification and resolution of discrepancies, the invoice is authorized for payment.
2 Way Matching in Accounts Payable an example Imagine your startup needs a regular supply of printer cartridges. You create a PO for ABC Ink specifying the type and quantity of cartridges at a negotiated price per unit. When ABC Ink delivers the cartridges and sends an invoice, a two way match verifies that the invoice reflects the exact details in the PO. This ensures you only pay for the ordered quantity at the agreed-upon price.
Benefits of 2 Way Matching in Accounts Payable for Startups Faster Approvals: 2-way matching streamlines invoice processing, leading to quicker payments for vendors, potentially improving supplier relationships.Reduced Workload: Automation simplifies the matching process, freeing up your AP team to focus on more strategic tasks through touchless processing and error reduction.Cost-Effective: 2-way matching is less resource-intensive compared to more complex matching methods, making it suitable for startups with limited staff and budgets, resulting in significant cost savings.Improved Accuracy: Automating the verification process minimizes human error and ensures accurate payments.Fraud Prevention: 2-way matching helps identify potential discrepancies that might indicate fraudulent activity.Challenges of 2 Way Matching in Accounts Payable Limited Scope: 2-way matching only verifies purchase orders and invoices. It doesn't account for physical receipt of goods, which might be crucial for certain purchases.Tolerance Thresholds: Setting appropriate tolerance levels is important. While too strict tolerances can delay approvals, overly lenient ones might overlook minor discrepancies.What is 3 Way Matching in Accounts Payable? 3-way matching is a comprehensive verification process in accounts payable (AP) that goes beyond comparing purchase orders and invoices. It adds a crucial layer of security by ensuring the physical receipt of goods or services aligns with what was ordered and billed, making the three way matching process more robust.
Imagine a three-legged stool - a purchase order, invoice, and goods receipt note (GRN) - each leg needs to be sturdy for the stool to stand firm. The 2 way 3 way match process verifies all three documents are in agreement before approving payment.
Steps in The 3 Way Matching Process 1. Goods Received: Upon delivery, designated personnel (e.g., warehouse staff) meticulously count or inspect the goods (or verify service completion) and document everything in a goods received note (GRN).
2. Data Entry: Details from the GRN, including quantity received and any discrepancies noted, are entered into the accounting system.
3. The 3-Way Match: The AP team compares the information on the:
Purchase Order (PO): What was ordered (quantity, price)Invoice: What was billed (quantity, price)Goods Receipt Note (GRN): What was actually received (quantity, condition)4. Tolerance Levels: Similar to 2-way matching, pre-defined tolerance limits might be applied. Minor discrepancies (e.g., slight variations in quantity) might be acceptable, while larger deviations trigger a hold on the invoice.
5. Discrepancy Resolution: Any inconsistencies beyond the tolerance level require investigation. The AP team might contact the vendor to clarify the mismatch before payment is authorized, often resulting in invoice holds and manual review.
6. Payment Approval: Once all three documents are verified and any discrepancies resolved, the invoice is approved for payment.
3 Way Matching in Accounts Payable an Example Your university bookstore places a PO with a supplier for 500 specific textbooks at a negotiated price per unit. Upon delivery, the receiving department verifies the quantity and condition of the books, documenting everything in a GRN. The three way matching process then ensures the invoice reflects the exact quantity and price agreed upon in the PO, and that the GRN confirms the accurate number of textbooks were received in good condition.
Benefits of 3 Way Matching in Accounts Payable Enhanced Fraud Detection: 3-way matching helps identify potential discrepancies that might indicate fraudulent activity, such as inflated invoices or phantom deliveries, which are often uncovered during audits.Improved Accuracy: Verifying physical receipt minimizes the risk of errors or overpayments based solely on PO and invoice details, contributing to significant error reduction.Stronger Internal Controls: The additional layer of verification strengthens internal controls by ensuring payments are made for authorized goods or services that have actually been received.Reduced Risk: For large-scale or high-value purchases, 3-way matching offers a more robust safety net.Challenges in 3 Way Matching in Accounts Payable Increased Processing Time: Verifying an additional document can add time to the invoice processing cycle.Resource Requirements: Implementing and managing 3-way matching might require additional staff or resources, especially for larger organizations.Potential for Bottlenecks: If discrepancies arise and require investigation, it could create bottlenecks in the payment process.Choosing between 2 way matching and 3 way matching for your Startup : The decision hinges on factors like:
Organizational Size and Risk Profile: Smaller businesses with lower-value transactions might find 2-way matching sufficient. For larger organizations or those dealing with high-risk purchases, 3-way matching offers a stronger safeguard.Internal Controls: Companies with robust internal controls might already have measures in place to mitigate some of the risks not addressed by 2-way matching alone.Cost-Benefit Analysis: The potential benefits of preventing fraud and ensuring accurate payments need to be weighed against the added time, resources, and potential cost savings required for 3-way matching.In the next section, we'll explore 4-way matching, an even more comprehensive verification process used in specific scenarios.
What is 4 Way Matching in Accounts Payable? Taking accounts payable a step further, 4-way matching offers the most stringent verification process. It involves meticulously comparing four key documents:
Invoices: The bill received from the vendor detailing the goods or services purchased and their corresponding costs.Purchase Orders (POs): Official documents issued by your startup to the vendor, outlining the specific items, quantities, and agreed-upon prices.Goods Receipts (GRNs): Documents confirming the physical receipt of the ordered goods at your startup's location, along with the received quantities, often referred to as a goods received note.Inspection Slips: Records generated after examining the delivered goods to ensure they meet quality standards as per the PO.Steps in 4 way matching in Accounts Payable Goods Arrival: The ordered items are delivered to your designated receiving area.GRN Creation: Upon receiving the goods, the receiving department verifies the quantities and creates a goods received note (GRN) reflecting the actual amount received.Inspection: A designated personnel inspects the delivered goods against the quality parameters outlined in the PO. This inspection is documented on an inspection slip.Invoice Matching: The accounts payable team receives the vendor's invoice and compares it to the PO, GRN, and inspection slip.Example of 4 way Matching in Accounts Payable: Imagine your startup ordered 10 laptops at a specific price through a PO. The GRN reflects the receipt of 10 laptops, but the inspection reveals that 2 laptops have minor cosmetic defects. In a 4-way match scenario, the invoice amount would only reflect the cost of 8 functioning laptops, as the inspection identified discrepancies.
Benefits of 4-Way Matching: Enhanced Quality Control: By incorporating an inspection step, 4-way matching ensures your startup receives not only the correct quantity but also goods that meet quality standards. This minimizes the risk of accepting defective products and incurring unnecessary return or replacement costs, leading to significant cost savings.Reduced Fraudulent Activity: The rigorous verification process deters potential invoice fraud attempts, as discrepancies between ordered and received quantities or quality issues are readily identified, aiding in thorough audits.Improved Cash Flow Management: With accurate invoice validation, you only pay for what you receive and confirm its quality, preventing overpayments and optimizing your startup's cash flow, which positively impacts the accounts payable turnover ratio.Challenges in 4 Way Matching in Accounts Payable: Increased Processing Time: The additional inspection step can lead to slightly longer processing times compared to simpler matching methods, affecting the overall invoice processing workflow .Resource Requirements: Implementing 4-way matching effectively may require allocating dedicated personnel for quality inspections, potentially impacting operational costs.The Choice for Your Startup While 4-way matching offers the most robust verification, it's essential to weigh its benefits against the potential drawbacks. For startups dealing with high-value or quality-critical goods, the enhanced control may outweigh the additional processing time. On the other hand, startups dealing with lower-risk, standardized products might find a 3-way matching process sufficient.
2 Way Match vs 3 Way Match vs 4 Way Match in AP Choosing the Right Match for Your Startup The best matching process for your startup depends on several factors, including:
Company Size: Smaller startups with limited resources might prioritize simpler methods like 2-way matching.Transaction Complexity: For complex transactions involving high-value goods or specialized services, 3-way or 4-way matching might be necessary, especially for non-recurring purchases.Risk Tolerance: Startups with low tolerance for fraud or quality issues would benefit from the enhanced control offered by 3-way or 4-way matching.Additional Considerations: Automation Tools: Consider leveraging accounts payable automation software to streamline the matching process, especially for high-volume transactions, regardless of the matching method chosen.Vendor Relationships: Strong relationships with reputable vendors can mitigate some of the risks associated with simpler matching methods.By carefully evaluating these factors, startup finance heads can select the most appropriate accounts payable matching process to optimize efficiency, control costs, and safeguard their business from fraud.
How Automation Can Help in Invoice processing Checks? Manual accounts payable processes, particularly matching invoices, can be time-consuming and prone to errors. Fortunately, accounts payable automation offers a powerful solution to streamline these tasks and empower your startup's financial team.
The Power of Automation: Automation tools can significantly enhance the matching process by:
Extracting Data Automatically: Automating data entry eliminates the need for manual data keying, reducing errors and saving valuable time, contributing to significant error reduction.Standardizing Matching Rules: Automation allows you to define clear matching rules for invoices, POs, and GRNs, ensuring consistent and accurate verification across all transactions, facilitating touchless processing.Streamlining Workflows: Automated workflows can route invoices for approval based on pre-defined criteria, expediting the payment process through an efficient invoice processing workflow.Enhancing Visibility: Automation tools provide real-time insights into your accounts payable processes, enabling better tracking and reporting of key accounts payable metrics .Benefits of Automation: By implementing automation, your startup can expect to reap several advantages:
Reduced Processing Time: Automation frees up your accounts payable team from tedious manual tasks, allowing them to focus on higher-value activities.Improved Accuracy: Automating data entry and matching rules minimizes the risk of human error, leading to more accurate and reliable financial records through effective error reduction.Enhanced Efficiency: Streamlined workflows simplify the entire matching process, boosting overall operational efficiency within your accounts payable department.Fraud Detection: Automation tools can help identify suspicious invoices or discrepancies, potentially preventing fraudulent activity.Popular Tools and Features: Several automation tools can be valuable assets for your startup's accounts payable processes. Here are a couple of examples:
Mysa : This platform offers features like automated data extraction, three-way matching, and workflow management, allowing you to customize matching rules and automate invoice approvals.RazorpayX S2P: This solution provides a comprehensive suite of accounts payable functionalities, including automated invoice capture, matching, and approval workflows, with features like vendor management and real-time payment tracking.To Sum it Up In the dynamic world of startups, efficient and secure accounts payable (AP) processes are fundamental for growth and survival. Manual invoice processing, riddled with errors and potential fraud risks, can significantly hinder your financial health. This guide has equipped you with the knowledge to navigate the different matching techniques – 2-way, 3-way, and 4-way matching – empowering you to choose the optimal approach for your startup's specific needs.
By understanding the strengths and limitations of each matching method, you can strike the perfect balance between efficiency and control. For startups with limited resources, 2-way matching might be sufficient, while those dealing with high-value or critical goods might benefit from the enhanced security of 3-way or 4-way matching.
The future of AP lies in automation. Leveraging automation tools can streamline your matching processes, minimize errors, and free up your team to focus on strategic initiatives. Remember to consider factors like company size, transaction complexity, and risk tolerance when selecting the most suitable automation solution.
By implementing robust matching techniques and embracing automation, you can transform your accounts payable function into a strategic asset, safeguarding your startup's financial well-being and fueling its success.
.webp)
.svg)
.svg)
.svg)
.png)
.png)
.svg)
.jpg)
